Head to head

Shirley Temple vs. Switchel

Shirley Temple and Switchel side by side: what changes in the recipe, the balance, the strength and the calories.

The difference, by the numbers

They have no ingredient in common: the Shirley Temple has grenadine, lemon juice and ginger ale, the Switchel water, molasses, cider vinegar and ground ginger. In parts, a Shirley Temple is 1 grenadine, 1¼ lemon and 22 ginger ale; a Switchel is 20 water, 2 molasses and 1 cider vinegar. By volume, the Shirley Temple is 90% mixer and juice, 6% citrus and 4% syrup and sugar; the Switchel is 87% mixer and juice, 9% syrup and sugar and 4% citrus. Different bottles, similar balance: that makes them close cousins on the ratio map.

They are about equally strong in the glass (both 0.0% ABV), and they hold about the same alcohol (0.00 standard drinks each). The Switchel has more calories (about 104 against 86) and more sugar (25.6 g against 19.9 g). Both are built and served in a highball.

Shirley Temple

Zero Proof · Zero proof

Strength
0.0%
Std. drinks
0.00
Calories
86
Sugar
19.9 g

Built, served in a highball. About 6½ oz (201 ml) in the glass. Garnish: A lemon wheel and a maraschino cherry.

The ratio · 1 : 1¼ : 22

Full Shirley Temple recipe →

Highlighted: not in the Switchel.

On the ratio map

SpiritVermouthCitrusMixerSyrupLiqueurShirley TempleSwitchel

Each drink sits nearer the corners it has more of: spirit, vermouth and bitter, citrus, mixer, syrup or liqueur. The gray dots are the other classics. Explore the full ratio map.