Head to head

Rusty Nail vs. Stinger

Rusty Nail and Stinger side by side: what changes in the recipe, the balance, the strength and the calories.

The difference, by the numbers

They have no ingredient in common: the Rusty Nail has Blended Scotch and Drambuie, the Stinger Cognac and crème de menthe. In parts, a Rusty Nail is 1¾ Scotch and 1 Drambuie; a Stinger is 2½ brandy and 1 menthe. By volume, the Rusty Nail is 64% spirit and 36% liqueur; the Stinger is 71% spirit and 29% liqueur. Different bottles, similar balance: that makes them close cousins on the ratio map.

The Rusty Nail is the stronger drink in the glass (32.0% ABV against 23.6%) and holds more alcohol (1.58 standard drinks against 1.40). The Rusty Nail has more calories (about 185 against 169), with about the same sugar (7.5 g and 8.0 g). The Rusty Nail is built and served in a rocks glass; the Stinger is stirred and served in a martini glass.

Rusty Nail

Old Fashioneds & Duos · Scotch

Strength
32.0%
Std. drinks
1.58
Calories
185
Sugar
7.5 g

Built, served in a rocks glass. About 3 oz (88 ml) in the glass. Garnish: Lemon peel.

The ratio · 1¾ : 1

Full Rusty Nail recipe →

Highlighted: not in the Stinger.

Stinger

Old Fashioneds & Duos · Brandy

Strength
23.6%
Std. drinks
1.40
Calories
169
Sugar
8.0 g

Stirred, served in a martini glass. About 3½ oz (105 ml) in the glass. Garnish: A mint leaf (optional).

The ratio · 2½ : 1

Full Stinger recipe →

Highlighted: not in the Rusty Nail.

On the ratio map

SpiritVermouthCitrusMixerSyrupLiqueurRusty NailStinger

Each drink sits nearer the corners it has more of: spirit, vermouth and bitter, citrus, mixer, syrup or liqueur. The gray dots are the other classics. Explore the full ratio map.

More head to heads

Rusty Nail vs.

Stinger vs.

All head to heads →